News

Supreme Court hearing which will determine the definition of a woman begins TODAY – in a case with major implications for female-only spaces

A Supreme Court hearing that will determine the definition of a woman begins today in a case with major implications for female-only spaces.

The case – which has been brought by gender-critical activists – will see five justices consider the question: ‘Is a person with a full gender recognition certificate which recognises that their gender is female, a ‘woman’ for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010?’

Feminist group For Women Scotland (FWS) will argue that trans women should not be able to fill roles meant for biological women under legislation designed to ensure equal numbers of men and women on company boards.

The Scottish government, which is contesting the case, insists the term woman includes a ‘person issued with a full GRC in the acquired gender of female’.

Gender-critical activists fear that, if they lose, it will render the definition of ‘woman’ in the Equality Act essentially meaningless.

They also argue that it will undermine women-only spaces and potentially trigger legal challenges over whether male-bodied criminals with a GRC should be held in a women’s prison.

A final ruling after the two-day hearing is not expected until next year. Harry Potter author JK Rowling has donated to FWS, saying last week: ‘If a man is a woman, there’s no such thing as a woman.’

Susan Smith, of FWS, said the case will have huge implications for women-only spaces and groups.

If FWS is unsuccessful ‘it will mean a lot of the advances and a lot of the progress that many women have made over the last few decades will be wiped out’, she added.

Helen Joyce, of human rights charity Sex Matters, said the case was ‘forcing the legal system to face up to the destructive ambiguity… concerning the legal definition of the word ‘woman’, which has done great harm to the rights of actual, flesh and blood women’.

The UK Supreme Court will hear a landmark case about the legal definition of a ‘woman’ today and Wednesday.

In 2018, Holyrood passed a law to increase the proportion of women sitting on the boards of public bodies to 50 per cent.

It defined ‘woman’ as including transgender women, whether or not they had a gender recognition certificate (GRC) changing their 𝑠e𝑥 in the eyes of the law.

The feminist group For Women Scotland (FWS) successfully challenged this at Scotland’s highest court, arguing it strayed beyond Holyrood’s powers.\

SNP ministers issued revised guidance on the issue, but this also stated that the definition of ‘woman’ included a trans person with a GRC.

FWS, who believe the Actwas meant to improve the representation of biological women on boards, not – as they would put it – men with GRCs, challenged the guidance.

FWS lost twice at the Court of Session and have now appealed to the UK Supreme Court. The Scottish Government has chosen to defend the case.

The dry court summary states the issue as: ‘Is a person with a full gender recognition certificate which recognises that their gender is female, a “woman” for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010?’

In practice, the result could have a profound effect on the gender debate in the UK.If FWS win, they hope it will cut through the ‘tortuous arguments’ of recent years and make biological 𝑠e𝑥 the defining quality for accessing services and spaces.

If FWS lose, they fear it will render the definition of ‘woman’ contained within the UK Equality Act essentially meaningless, undermine women-only services and spaces, and trigger legal challenges over whether male-bodied criminals witha GRC should be held in a women’s prison.

Lord Reed and four other justices are expected to deliver their opinion in the spring.

Related Posts

Labour’s big new ‘back to work’ threat to strip youngsters of their benefits if they are unwilling to graft or train already happens, admits minister –  and they can appeal if it’s too harsh

Labour’s big ‘back to work’ threat to strip unwilling teens of their benefits if they don’t try to get a job or train is just a continuation of the current system, a senior minister admitted today. Alison McGovern was grilled over the drive to ‘get Britain working again’ and achieve an ‘ambitious’ target of getting another 2 million people into jobs. As well as targeting the long-term sick, ministers have also vowed that those aged 18 to 21 who are out of work but refuse to look for a job, seek training or an apprenticeship, will get no taxpayer cash.

Israel and Hezbollah on the cusp of a peace deal: Netanyahu ‘gives green light to ceasefire proposal’

A ceasefire deal between Israel and Hezbollah could see the terrorist organisation leave southern Lebanon and the IDF withdraw its troops. The deal, which reportedly has the support of Israel’s prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, could see the nearly two-month military incursion to come to an end. A source within the government told the Daily Telegraph that the Israeli cabinet will vote on the proposals drawn up by the United States today.

Reason I’m A Celebrity’s Tulisa and Reverend Richard Coles are exempt from height trials is revealed

I’m A Celebrity fans discovered last night that Tulisa and Reverend Richard Coles were exempt from height trials, with the N-Dubz singer accidentally revealing hers was on ‘medical grounds’. Before the voting opened for tonight’s Bushtucker trial, the show’s longtime hosts Ant and Dec announced Tulisa, 36, and Reverend Coles, 62, would be exempt from the trial with no further explanation. Fans were left speculating as to why even when the Geordie duo told the camp Dean McCullough, 32, was going to face a trial yet again.

New bank holiday planned to mark major event anniversary in 2025

Brits are to get a new bank holiday next year to mark the 80th anniversary of the end of the Second World War – with a bumper four-day weekend planned. The major celebration will be marking the heroics of the ‘Greatest Generation’ who fought against Hitler and the Nazis in Europe and Africa, and Imperial Japan in Asia. And as part of a big year of events, a four-day jamboree will reportedly be staged either in May or August.

Gavin Newsom proposes ‘insane’ move against Elon Musk as he attempts to defy Trump with electric car rebates that excludes Tesla

Gavin Newsom is plotting to defy Donald Trump while stiffing key MAGA ally Elon Musk, as California plans an electric vehicle rebate program that intentionally leaves out Tesla. The California governor is planning to introduce a state tax rebate on purchasing electric cars if the Trump administration eliminates the federal tax cut. Newsom even bragged that his policies have made Tesla and Musk ‘so damn successful.’

Santas sacked for ‘being right wing’:  Hunger strike grandfather is ousted for Reform support – as pensioner’s anti-Labour social media posts get him  banned from donating to food bank

Two local Santas have been given the ‘sack’ for expressing right-wing political views. Paul Cleary, 70, of Wath upon Dearne in South Yorkshire, volunteers as Father Christmas for a local charity each year, offering visits to families and attending the lights switch-on with the Lord Mayor. However, this year he has been left distraught after being told the group is dispensing with his services due to his anti-Labour social media posts, as well as being advised not to use the money he raises as Santa to donate to the local food bank.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *