With his accessories, the musician artfully tip-toed the line between formal and casual, pairing sleek black dress shoes with a backward snapback — a Justin staple — in white, to match his undershirt.

BACKGRID

Justin Bieber and Hailey Bieber’s Relationship Timeline

Hailey, 27, on the other hand, was a vision in red, getting into the holiday spirit with a cherry-red statement jacket.

The effortlessly chic model wore fuzzy, calf-length outerwear similar to the head-turning Stella McCartney teddy coat Taylor Swift bundled up in earlier this month.

Justin and Hailey Bieber in 2023.

JERRITT CLARK/GETTY IMAGES

The rest of the Rhode Skin founder’s ensemble was a classic Hailey look – slicked-back hair, sheer tights, pointed pumps, simple-but-chunky earrings and a pair of black, ‘90s-inspired sunnies.

She also complemented the Elmo-chic coat with a red lip, which popped against her icy makeup, which resembled the “sugar plum”-inspired look she dubbed her go-to winter “vibe” in a November TikTok. (So long, “strawberry girl summer.”)

Hailey Bieber Stars in Calvin Klein’s Holiday Campaign — Get an Exclusive Look Behind the Scenes

Other 2023 fashion highlights of the the Biebers’ include their Halloween ensembles, low-key coffee-date style and myriad street style looks.

The pair made headlines earlier this year for their couple’s style after social media users called out the couple for their often mismatching ensembles.

The criticism peaked in August, when Hailey got dolled up in a red mini dress and matching heels to promote Rhode’s Strawberry Glaze lippie, and Justin supported her in a very casual ensemble — gray sweats, yellow Crocs and a pink trucker hat.

Hailey Bieber Confirms Husband Justin Bieber Uses Rhode Skincare Products: ‘Men, This Is for You, Too’Justin and Hailey Bieber faced criticism for their conflicting couple style earlier this year.

GOTHAM/GC IMAGES

Months later, the model and beauty mogul addressed the online chatter about their conflicting looks in a November cover story for GQ Hype.

“It’s so funny because I see so many people talk about this,” she told the outlet. “He may want to wear baggy sweats to dinner, and I might want to wear a tiny little dress just because that’s how I’m feeling.”

“We can’t sit there and be like, ‘So I’m going to wear this and you’re going to wear this,’” she said of her and her musician husband, whom she said tends to get dressed before her.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Of the day she sported the Strawberry Glaze-inspired ensemble, she told GQ Hype, “It’s like, it wasn’t Justin’s day. It was Hailey’s day. He’s there to support his wife, period.”

Added Hailey: “But also, he still looks cool, so you can’t hate the guy.”